Name: Mona Z.
Date: Sept. 17, 2010
Class: IDC4U
OTTAWA – The use of cellphones are banned in most schools across Ontario, but may cellphones or blackberrys become handy and effective for a student's education? Ontario's Premier Dalton McGuinty recently told reporters at Queen's Park, Toronto that schools in Ontario should allow students to use cellphones in the classroom. McGuinty stated that the use of cellphones benefit students in the classroom by writing their notes, or quick reminders onto their cellphones or blackberrys as technology is increasing day by day. “ I feel more alert in class when I type my notes on my cellphone because I'm not scribbling when I am writing on a piece of paper... when I type my notes on my cellphone I actually understand what I am typing.” said Jessica Thomas – a grade 10 student of Colonel By Secondary School. This is creating a big uproar for parents as well as students in Ontario. Many parents agree with the fact that the use of cellphones are banned during school time, though other parents disagree with the issue of cellphones being banned. The use of cellphones for students during school remains very controversial as there are many pros and cons regarding this issue.
Some pros which many parents had said was that they can be in touch with their children and be informed of their whereabouts, they can reach their children in case of an emergency, if their children are in danger they can contact their parents or police immediately, and lastly cellphones can be on silent during school hours.
“ I am a diplomat and I travel quite frequently, and I always call my kids at school to know how they are or if they need anything. Cellphones are an important tool for my kids and I” Said Julie Morrison, mother of two students attending Gloucester High School. Many schools nowadays use technology for many reasons such as smart boards used in math classes and morning announcements which is heard and seen though a television which is in every room of a school. Sir Wilfred Laurier High School and Colonel By Secondary School use this advanced style of technology and are the only two high schools in Ottawa with this system. Nowadays if you ask a classroom of students who owns a cellphone, everyone would raise their hand up except for maybe one or two students; but if the same question was asked eight to nine years ago, the result would have been the opposite – only one or two students would raise their hand up saying they own a cellphone. The population of students who own a cellphone has increased drastically according to Stats Canada in the past decade. Many teachers and parents say this is a big issue which is affecting a student's learning because cellphones are a big distraction for students during school hours.
The main cons for the use of cellphones which parents and teachers had repeated often was that students usually forget to turn off their phones, text message others which disrupt a student's learning as it became the new style of note passing, fake threats to people or places – causing more violence, rampant cellphone use can overload communication systems and render them inoperable, can be used as a cheating device during exams and tests, and lastly spread rumours amongst friends through picture/video messages. Many teachers waste half of their teaching time complaining to students about turning off their cellphones, or to pay attention to class lessons instead of reading text messages. “ Being a high school teacher makes me feel like I'm teaching a bunch of kindergardeners to put their shoes on when going outside.” Said a high school teacher of Lisgar Collegiate Institute. “Students should pay a fine if the use of cellphones are seen around school,” said Grade 12 student Christy Harrison. “Students usually lose focus on texting friends, and not paying attention for class.
The controversy of students using cellphones in school is creating many problems nowadays – teachers, parents, and students all have different opinions towards the use of cellphones during school hours and school grounds which is a huge problem to solve as technology is growing each and every day. “In my days, we weren't even allowed to use calculators! Now McGuinty is thinking of not to ban cell phones in schools!” Said Mariana, aged 78.
When and how will this controversy towards students using cellphones in school come to an end? Will people agree with McGuinty's opinion of cellphones actually being helpful for a student's learning at school? Well, the outcome for this controversy will take quite some time, and will be longly awaited by students, teachers, and most concerned – parents.

No comments:
Post a Comment